#6 How to ask AI
The same task, five different prompts. Switch ingredients on and watch the answer change.
Write an offer
- Thursday. Jana’s colleague Martin has a customer.Martin: Write an offer.AI: Done. “Hello, we would like to introduce our offer…”
- Martin: This says nothing. Not a word about the coffee machine or the hotel.AI: You didn’t say a word to me about the coffee machine or the hotel either.
- Martin: Jana, your AI is broken. I wrote “Write an offer” and got a leaflet.Jana: And what did you tell it about the offer?Martin: That it should write it. It’s AI, it can work the rest out.Jana: You know how it writes, right? It continues the text it was given.
- AI: I got three words. I continued with what most often comes after them. A general leaflet.
How it works
An answer is only as good as the prompt
A chatbot continues the text you give it (episode 2). Everything missing from the prompt, it fills in with what is most common in similar texts. A general prompt gets a general answer.
There is no magic and no secret formula. It just needs something to hold on to: who it is writing for, what it needs to know, what the result should look like and what should not be in it.
- Jana: Let’s try again. The same task, but I’ll tell you more, step by step.AI: The more I know, the less I make up. Switch them on.
- Your turn!General
Watch how the email changes.
Switch the ingredients of the prompt on and off.
Ingredients
Your prompt
Write an offer.
The AI's answer
AI: Hello, we would like to introduce our offer. Our company provides high-quality products and services at attractive prices, and customer satisfaction is our priority. If you are interested, do not hesitate to contact us. Kind regardsAI: I know almost nothing about the task. The rest I made up.Whatever is not in the prompt, the chatbot fills in with the most common thing. Or makes it up. How it works
The five ingredients of a prompt
Did you notice the 10% discount? Nobody offered it. The chatbot added it, because discounts usually appear in offers. That is what the limits are for.
The order and the exact words do not matter. What matters is that the prompt answers five questions. You do not have to write all of them every time, but each one that is missing leaves room for guesswork.
- Who for, and from whom: who will read the result, and who is sending it.
- What to know: facts, numbers, background. What you do not paste in, it does not have.
- What it looks like: length, form, tone, what should come at the end.
- An example: a sample of how you do it says more than three adjectives.
- Limits: what must not be in it, and what it must not promise.
Magic words
- One coffee laterMartin: I know what went wrong. I forgot the magic words. My cousin always starts with “Please, you are the best expert in the world”.Jana: And does your cousin write better offers?
- Martin: Please, you are the best expert in the world at writing offers. Write an offer.AI: Thank you. I still don’t know who for or what about. I don’t mind politeness, but what makes the difference is what you tell me.
- Martin: Then I’ll give it a really long prompt. A page and a half about our company, our history, our values…Jana: Long isn’t the same as clear. A page about values and nothing about the coffee machine. It will make it up again.
- Martin: But it knows that already. It’s all on our website, and I forwarded Ms Moreno’s email yesterday.AI: I haven’t read your website. And you forwarded that email to a colleague, not to me. I only see what you paste in.
How it works
Four myths about prompts
There is a lot of advice going around about prompts. Most of it is about form instead of content.
- Magic words solve everything. Politeness or the title “expert” does no harm and changes the tone of the answer a little. But information makes the difference, not the way you address it. A role is useful when it says something about the task (you write for a company that rents out coffee machines).
- A long prompt is better. Length is not what matters. What matters is whether the prompt answers the five questions, not how many lines it has.
- It reads minds. About your task, it knows only what you write. What is in your head, you have to write down.
- It sees your files. It cannot see into your computer or your email until you connect it to them, with your permission. Some chatbots can search the web (more about that in the next episode), but it is safer to paste in the part it needs.
The second message
- In the afternoonMartin: A customer’s coffee machine hasn’t worked for two days, and he’s complaining. Reply to him.AI: Writing.
- AI: “Dear Customer, we sincerely apologise for the inconvenience caused. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we take this situation extremely seriously. We assure you that we are doing everything we can to resolve it as quickly as possible. Thank you for your understanding.”Martin: Four sentences of apologies, and not a word about when we’ll fix it.
- Jana: So tell it what’s wrong. You don’t have to start again.Martin: Just another message? I thought I had to come up with the perfect prompt.
- Your turn!
Which next message will fix Martin’s draft?
How it works
A second message instead of the perfect prompt
The perfect first prompt does not exist, and looking for it is a waste of time. It is quicker to write what you have, look at the result and fix it with a second message: what is wrong, what is missing, what should stay.
The chatbot has in its notebook what you wrote in that conversation (episode 5), so you do not need to repeat the whole prompt while the conversation is short. Just say what should change.
Let it ask
- FridayJana: One more thing. “Write an offer for Hotel Aurora. Before you start, ask me about everything you are missing.”AI: How long do they want to rent it for? Does the price also apply to two machines? Until when should the offer be valid?
- Jana: Wow, you’re missing the answers to three questions! And two of them hadn’t even occurred to me.AI: I would have made them up. This way we find out before I write anything.
- Martin: Let me sum it up. Who for, what to know, what it looks like, an example, limits. And if it writes rubbish, I tell it what’s wrong.Jana: And if you don’t know what to tell it, let it ask you.
How it works
Let it ask
One sentence at the end of a prompt saves the most work: “If anything is missing, ask me first.” The chatbot will then usually ask about what it is missing instead of making it up.
It works the other way round too. If you are not sure it has understood you, have it repeat the task in its own words before it starts writing.
Quiz
- AI: To finish, five questions. The task is clear: no marks.Jana: A clear prompt, at last.
- Quiz
Question 1 of 5
Five questions, no marks.
Martin wrote “Write an offer.” and got a general leaflet. Why?
Choose one answer.
What to take away
- A chatbot continues the text it was given. Whatever is missing from the prompt, it fills in with the most common thing, or makes it up.
- A good prompt says who it is for, what the chatbot needs to know, what the result should look like and what must not be in it. An example says more than adjectives.
- Politeness does no harm, but it is not what makes the difference. Neither is length on its own.
- It cannot see into your head or into your files. What you do not paste in, it does not have.
- Do not hunt for the perfect prompt. Tell it what is wrong, and let it ask you questions.
Next episode
#7 Where AI gets it from
A chatbot that searches the web sounds even more certain. Find out what the link under an answer proves, and what it doesn’t.
New episodes straight to your inbox
Every two weeks we send the new episodes, a short learning note and news from the world of AI. Free, and you can unsubscribe any time.